Former Demorest employee sues city, alleges sexual harassment and retaliation

DEMOREST, Ga. – A former City of Demorest employee has filed a federal lawsuit accusing City Manager Mark Musselwhite of repeated unwanted touching and demeaning comments and alleging the city retaliated against her after she reported his conduct.

The lawsuit adds another layer to months of upheaval inside Demorest’s government — particularly its police department — where an outside investigation found a “toxic atmosphere,” employees have steadily resigned, former Police Chief Casey Chastain blamed Musselwhite for much of the turmoil, and the city has spent money on professional mediation.

Rachel Blasberg filed the 26-page complaint Sept. 30 in U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Georgia against the City of Demorest and former co-workers Rachel Bryant and Amy Payne. She alleges sexual harassment and a hostile work environment under Title VII, retaliation, violations of the Georgia Whistleblower Act, and defamation.

Blasberg could not comment because of the ongoing litigation.

Now Georgia contacted Musselwhite for a response to the allegations. He had not responded as of publication.

The allegations have not been proven in court, and the filing represents Blasberg’s account of what occurred.

‘It was he’

Blasberg worked for Demorest beginning in October 2022, first part-time and later full-time as a Georgia Crime Information Center operator and utility clerk working within the police department and court system, according to the lawsuit. She alleges she had never received written discipline and had received positive evaluations, including ratings of “exceptional” and “exceeds expectations.”

The lawsuit says that changed following an internal investigation that began after Bryant and Payne raised concerns about Chastain’s relationship with Blasberg.

An outside investigator the city retained later found a friendly relationship between Blasberg and Chastain but wrote that “nothing struck me as inappropriate.” The investigator concluded allegations involving physical contact between the two appeared to involve friendly, innocuous behavior rather than anything sexual.

The same investigation found something else: “there is clearly a toxic atmosphere in this office.”

That finding became the foundation of months of Now Georgia reporting on deteriorating working relationships inside the police department.

Blasberg’s lawsuit now presents a sharply different allegation about inappropriate contact.

She claims Musselwhite repeatedly hugged her, touched her back and arms, and called her “baby” in front of coworkers. She alleges the contact was unwanted and that she tried to pull away or avoid it.

According to the complaint, Musselwhite questioned Blasberg again on Feb. 24 about allegations involving Chastain. During that meeting, Blasberg says she denied anything inappropriate had happened with Chastain and instead reported that Musselwhite was the one who had repeatedly touched her and called her “baby.”

The distinction is important because, according to the city charter cited in the complaint, the city manager also performs personnel and human-resources functions for Demorest.

In effect, Blasberg alleges she reported harassment to the same official she was accusing of committing it.

Job duties removed, then termination

Blasberg alleges retaliation followed.

The complaint says most of her job duties were removed around March 27, about a month after she accused Musselwhite of inappropriate conduct and refused to make what she says would have been false statements about Chastain. She was terminated April 17.

The lawsuit says the city cited “lack of work” and listed “budget constraints” on her Georgia Department of Labor separation notice.

Blasberg disputes those reasons.

She alleges Musselwhite told employees during an April 13 meeting that she had performed more work than her coworkers. She also claims Musselwhite told the city council Demorest was in the “best financial condition that it had ever been” and that the city hired employees after she was terminated.

Blasberg filed discrimination and retaliation charges with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission in June and received notices allowing her to sue in July and September, according to the complaint.

She is seeking lost wages and benefits, reinstatement or front pay, compensatory and punitive damages, attorney’s fees and other relief.

Former coworkers sued

Bryant and Payne are also defendants.

Blasberg alleges the women falsely told the city that Chastain was “touchy” with her and had rubbed her arms, shoulders and back. She says the allegations damaged her professional reputation and eventually became public through records a local newspaper obtained.

The complaint alleges Bryant and Payne made those statements together on Jan. 30 and claims they described conduct they said they personally witnessed but that Blasberg says never happened.

Neither the filing of a defamation claim nor Blasberg’s characterization of their statements establishes that Bryant or Payne made knowingly false statements. Those issues would have to be decided through the litigation.

Bryant later joined Demorest’s continuing employee exodus. She resigned in September along with Officer Edward Bush.

Months of turmoil

The lawsuit comes as Demorest continues to deal with a series of departures and management disputes that have played out publicly throughout 2026.

The city council authorized an investigation into internal police department personnel complaints in February.

That investigation ultimately found fractured relationships among civilian police employees and described the workplace as toxic. It recommended decisive management action, warning that an environment where employees dread coming to work was “a recipe for failure.”

The problems did not end with the investigation.

Former Sgt. Steven Squires resigned in May and later accused city leaders in his resignation letter of letting the investigation become what he called a “witch hunt.” He also described what he considered hostile treatment of another officer.

Assistant Chief James Minutello left in September to become an investigator with the Habersham County Sheriff’s Office. Bryant and Bush followed. Former civilian employee Miranda Kemp also resigned.

Then Chastain resigned.

In two resignation letters obtained by Now Georgia, the former chief directly blamed Musselwhite for much of the turmoil, accused city leaders of failing to adequately respond to his concerns, and said the working relationship had deteriorated to the point that he believed leaving was his only option.

Staffing losses became severe enough that Chastain began working patrol shifts personally and discussed contingency coverage with Habersham County Sheriff Robin Krockum.

Demorest has since appointed veteran law enforcement officer Brad Rounds as interim police chief. At the time of his appointment, Now Georgia reported eight officers and three civilian employees had left the department in recent months.

Questions now move to federal court

Blasberg’s lawsuit does not establish a single cause for the broader turmoil inside Demorest City Hall.

The earlier administrative investigation focused primarily on interpersonal problems among civilian police employees and did not substantiate allegations that Chastain engaged in inappropriate physical conduct. The federal lawsuit, by contrast, accuses Musselwhite of harassment and accuses the city of retaliating after Blasberg complained.

Those claims will now be tested in federal court.

The lawsuit also puts the city’s executive management under a new level of scrutiny at a time when Demorest is already rebuilding a police department depleted by resignations and answering questions about how employee complaints were handled.

Don’t miss what everyone in town is talking about.

Join 4,000+ locals and choose our free newsletter covering news, events and the stories shaping our region.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.